It has been authorised by ministers in the UK, subject to large public disapproval and has now delayed until next summer
but South West Conservative MEP Julie Girling
is firm in her belief that the culling of badgers is necessary to control the spread of Bovine TB among cattle.
In an interview with EU Reporter
she said: “I feel it is necessary because there is a strong belief and science to support it that unless we deal with the TB issue in the wildlife reservoir – which in the case of the UK is largely badgers but is also an issue with deer - we will not be able to eradicate TB in cattle."
"I think it will happen, the Secretary of State [Owen Paterson, Conservative] is absolutely clear and is going to make sure it happens and it reinforces in my mind that it is one of the tools in the toolbox for combating this dreadful disease.
She also spoke about her recent meeting with the European Commission where she asked about the possibility of a vaccination (as advocated by the likes of Dr Brian May on a recent trip to Brussels
) and said “the Commission takes the view that no vaccine currently exists and they have not been asked to authorise one as yet.
“There are different views from different veterinary sources, but the general view that seems to prevail as far as I can see is that the current vaccine would only work in about 60% of cases on cattle, would not cure cattle that already have TB, and it would be impossible to put vaccinated meat into the food chain in Europe because you would not know, there is no test, if it has been vaccinated or if there is some TB present,
” she said
Asked whether she understood why the vaccination is being viewed as the ‘holy grail’ to resolving the problem, she agreed. “I fully understand why, because goodness nobody wants to cull badgers; when you start to talk about it and think about the vaccine it seems like the answer. Absolutely, I clutched at that one myself.”
“But the reality is quite different as I have discovered,
” she continued
, “we are not the only country that has Bovine TB: many are now free having followed an eradication programme in line with the Commission’s advice, many are on the point of becoming TB-free although it may take a number of years before it is officially declared, and if you take the situation of a country like Spain – which had a similar situation to that of the UK - what they did was put into place the eradication programme in conjunction with culling their wildlife reservoir, which in their case was deer.
She criticised the “mixed messages
” that have been circulated and urged those who think vaccination is the answer to reconsider and “to think about it very carefully
The full video interview is below.
Labels: Julie Girling